My Green Mattress Review: A Top Non-Toxic Mattress Brand

Shopping for an organic mattress for yourself or your kids? Check out my detailed My Green Mattress review to help you make the best choice.

My Green Mattress is a family-owned mattress company located in Illinois. Since 2007, they have been making organic crib and adult mattresses. My Green Mattress is one of the most popular mattress brands among my readers, and I’m also a customer myself.

Given the company’s commitment to making quality organic mattresses on a budget, and my great experience working with them, they’ve made it to my list of the top 10 organic mattress companies and best organic crib mattresses for babies.

If you’re shopping for a new mattress, My Green Mattress offers exceptional value and quality and should definitely be on your list of organic mattress companies to consider.

About the Company

My Green Mattress is owned by Tim Masters, who is truly devoted to making the best mattresses possible. He grew up working as an apprentice the Quality Sleep Shop in La Grange Highlands, Illinois and eventually went on to buy the entire company. He launched My Green Mattress as an extension of the brand.

Tim is a mattress guy, through and through and it is obvious when you speak to him just how devoted he is to making the best mattresses he can. He confessed to me that he loves to take apart mattresses and tinker with them so that he can build the best mattresses for his customers – and I believe that you can tell when you sleep on one of their mattresses!

After his daughter, Emily, suffered from allergies and eczema, he and his wife, Cindy, learned firsthand the importance of avoiding harsh chemicals. (I can attest to that!) So, the Emily Natural Crib Mattress was born.

The company also offers an expansive line of adult and children’s mattress.

My Green Mattress Review

As the happy owner of two mattresses from My Green Mattress, and an affiliate of the company for almost three years, I feel especially qualified to write this review. I received a complimentary twin-sized mattress in exchange for my feedback, but as always, my reviews are honest and always my own. I’ll always tell you the good and the bad about any product or company – no matter what.

Mattresses:

My Green Mattress offers six mattress for you to choose from:

Emily Natural Crib Mattress: One of my reader favorites, the Emily Natural Crib Mattress is an excellent organic mattress at an affordable price. The Emily is made with the finest organic materials, including GOTS-certified cotton, coconut coir bound together with GOLS-certified latex, and natural wool. It features 150 heavy gauge innerspring coils and is double sided.

Kiwi Green Mattress: (NEW!) The newest addition to the My Green Mattress family, the Kiwi Green Mattress is likely going to be one of their best sellers. Similar to the Pure Echo (and about the same price) but made with less cotton, the Kiwi Green mattress has added layers of pure GOLS-certified latex and delivers a more comfortable night’s sleep. This bed is perfect for a big kid bed or a guest room – or even a shopper who’s on a budget. We have one of these in the kids’ room and it is so comfortable! I would say it is firm without feeling hard – and it’s a great choice for kids.

Pure Echo Mattress: The Pure Echo is MGM’s budget innerspring mattress that’s also great for kids rooms, guest rooms, or shoppers on a tight budget. It is an innerspring mattress made with an GOTS-certified organic cotton cover, natural wool, and organic cotton batting. If you’re stuck deciding between the Pure Echo and the Kiwi mattress, I would lean toward the Kiwi because it is going to be more comfortable than the Pure Echo. However the main difference is the use of latex, so if you need to avoid latex for any reason, the Pure Echo would be a good choice for you.

Natural Escape Mattress: My Green Mattress’s top of the line mattress, the Natural Escape is a luxurious but firm mattress. This is the mattress I sleep on, and co-sleep on, and I love how firm it is. And I’m not even someone who likes firm mattresses! But once I switched over from a soft, toxic mattress to my Natural Escape, I noticed how much better I felt in the mornings. Most of my backaches and neck pain disappeared once I started sleeping on a firmer mattress. So I’m definitely a firm-mattress fan now 🙂

Hope Latex Mattress: If you are looking for an all-latex mattress, the Hope Latex Mattress is a great choice for you! Get this mattress if you are looking for a plusher bed without polyurethane foam or those questionable “gels” commonly found in memory foam mattresses.

MGM also sells latex mattress toppers, waterproof mattress covers (which we have and love – they are soft!), and latex pillows.

Materials Used

My Green Mattress makes organic mattresses on a budget, and since they sell direct to consumer, they pass the saving on to their customers. Their mattresses are made with such fine materials as:

• GOTS certified organic cotton
• organic cotton
• GOLS certified Dunlop latex
• eco wool

All My Green Mattress products are handmade in the United States at the company’s factory in La Grange Highlands, Illinois.

100-Night Trial

When it comes to buying a mattress online, I understand that it can be a little intimidating. You don’t know exactly what to expect because you haven’t touched the mattress or laid on it in a store.

Feeling apprehensive about making such a big purchase sight unseen is totally normal. I felt that way too!

But what gave me comfort was My Green Mattress’s 100-Night Trial period. They allow you to return or exchange your mattress within the 100-night period – so long as you’ve given the mattress a chance for 30 days. So after you’ve slept on the mattress for 30 days, you’re free to return or exchange the mattress within the trial period.

There are some limitations to this trial, so be sure to read the most up-to-date policy on their website. Some mattress companies will only give you a store credit, so this policy is fair and generous to the customer, in my opinion.

Flexible Payment Plan

Buying a non-toxic mattress can be a big investment for anyone, so I like that My Green Mattress also offers a payment plan. If you’d like to pay for your mattress and other accessories on a payment plan, you can select this option at checkout.

Delivers to Your Door

Your mattress will be delivered straight to your doorstep, usually within two weeks of your order. It is compressed and rolled up and you can simply open the package and your bed will expand to its full size.

While this will provide you a big cost savings on delivery, I personally would have appreciated the option of paying a little extra for white glove service. For us, this was especially challenging because we live in a two-story home and ordered a California King mattress.

It was also hard because we didn’t think to bring the box upstairs to the master bedroom before opening it. So it was hard to transfer the 140-pound mattress upstairs.

Lesson learned: be sure to bring the box to the bedroom before opening it.

Airing Out the Mattress

Some MGM mattress models may contain more cotton and wool than others, so you may notice an “earthy” smell. Some people do and some people don’t. Some mattresses have it and some don’t.

• Natural Escape: Yes, I noticed an earthy smell
• Kiwi Green Mattress: No, I didn’t notice a smell

The Kiwi mattress was actually designed to contain less cotton and wool for this reason. So you can rest assured when buying the Kiwi mattress.

When we received our Natural Escape mattress, my husband opened it and immediately noticed the odor.

So we let the mattress air out for a few days and thankfully, the odor did go away. (During this time I assure you that my husband thought I was crazy and told me that we had to return the mattress. But the odor went away – 100%!)

It just needed to be aired out for a few days.

And now, over one year later, I can attest to the fact that my Natural Escape mattress still has absolutely no odor.

It’s just a short-term issue, and truly one that I don’t worry about too much. I would rather smell wool and cotton for a few days than breathe in flame retardant chemicals while I sleep.

Why I Chose My Green Mattress

When buying a mattress for myself, I chose My Green Mattress for a few key reasons:
1) The materials are organic and high-quality. I also love that the mattress is GREENGUARD gold certified.
2) The pricing. My Green Mattress sells their mattresses at an affordable price. I definitely wasn’t looking to spend $2K or more on a non-toxic mattress.
3) The 100-night guarantee eased my concerns with ordering a mattress over the internet without trying it out in person. And it has a 7-year warranty.
4) I have a great relationship with the company and they have earned my trust.

I knew the risks were that we wouldn’t like the mattress or it would be uncomfortable, and that the mattress would have an “earthy” odor. There are lots of reviews on their site that say the mattress they received had no odor and there are plenty that also say theirs did have a strong odor. So I knew it was a possibility one way or another.

Given the company’s generous return policy and how much I wanted one of their mattresses I decided to go for it.

After having my Natural Escape mattress for over a year now, I am still thrilled with my purchase.  It is very firm and comfortable at the same time. And it feels good knowing we are sleeping on safe materials. Even my husband said it’s a great mattress and you know that a skeptical hubby’s endorsement means a lot!

So now I recommend their crib and adult-size mattresses with even more confidence. My Green Mattress is a great company and they make quality products.